Hank Stuever

Author

  • home
  • books
  • bio
  • blog
  • tv criticism
  • media room
  • contact

Popular Culture Journalism (JOUR494): Class recap for Dec. 3 — reviewing the reviewers

December 3, 2012 by Hank Stuever Leave a Comment

Continuing my end-of-semester metaphor — this is what it’s like:

Today, however, we turned our attention to the criticism/reviews that students filed this semester. The TV recappers — Heather Jurva, Levi Hunt, Caitlyn Walsh — had to file five, 500-word recaps of consecutive episodes, and did so quite ably. Levi nitpicked “The Walking Dead,” even as he praised it; Caitlyn hilariously broke down this extra-loony season of “Dexter”; and Heather called “American Horror Story” on its own BS and took it to task for being such a mess this season.

We moved on to the reviews: Three “Lincoln” reviews, plus “Red Dawn,” “Looper,” “Trouble with the Curve,” “Rise of the Guardians” and “Life of Pi.”

Albums? Yes — Mumford & Sons, Taylor Swift, Philip Phillips, Lupe Fiasco and the Evens.

The rest? An art exhibit called “Evanescent”; a novel called “Storm Dancer”; the Pearl Jam concert to get votes for Montana Sen. Jon Tester; Bill O’Reilly’s “Killing Kennedy” and, last but not least, an energetic review of “Borderlands 2,” a video game, from Tom Holm.

That’s just a sampling of what was turned in on Oct. 3 and Nov. 26. The reviews were okay — and I gave full credit to students for turning them in — but only two or three truly stood out. I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again: Writing reviews is hard, hard work. It’s one of those jobs that looks a whole lot easier than it is. Still, I encourage everyone to keep honing their critical skills. In one way or another, you’re going to need it — maybe not as a paid cultural critic, but certainly in this crazy-mixed-up world we live in, with its Yelp!-style consumer reviews, etc. Having an articulate, meaningful opinion is the currency in this culture, whether you’re in the pages of the New Yorker or trying to explain your reaction to a presentation in a business meeting. Abstractions (“it was good”; “that was awesome”) are more empty than ever. People get ahead now by being sharp and by keeping up.

For Wednesday, Dec. 5: Our last class. Bring Kleenex. But most of all, file your final assignment no later than 5 p.m.

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: Caitlyn Walsh, criticism, Heather Jurva, Jour494, journalism, Levi Hunt, Pollner professor, Popular culture j, reviews, Tom Holm, University of Montana School of Journalism, writing

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Follow Us on RSSFollow Us on FacebookFollow Us on Twitter

Recent Posts

  • I got nowhere else to go
  • Not forgetting, but forgiving
  • Chuh-click-click. (One of my favorites)
  • Book giveaway! Book giveaway! GRANDMA GATEWOOD’S WALK by Gangrey’s Ben Montgomery
  • Frankincense and whirr

Recent Comments

  • Nancy Adkisson on Not forgetting, but forgiving
  • Liz on Not forgetting, but forgiving
  • Laura Keefe on Not forgetting, but forgiving
  • Jolene on Not forgetting, but forgiving
  • Linda on Not forgetting, but forgiving

Archives

Tags

1980s Albuquerque Tribune Austin book promotion book reviews books book tour Brooks Johnson Carli Krueger criticism Curtis Sittenfeld Dan Savage Dan Zak David Finkel David Finkel story about family who watches television Derba Eben Keller Frisco Texas Gangrey Gene Weingarten Hank Stuever Heather Jurva Henry Allen Joan Didion Jour494 journalism Journalism 494 Martha Sherrill Monica Hesse newspaper design newspapers Oklahoma City One-Man Book Club Pollner Pollner professor Popular Culture Journalism class SNL Homowatch Style section T. Anthony Pollner Tampa Bay Times television tinsel University of Montana School of Journalism Washington Post writing

Copyright © 2021 Hank Stuever